CANADIANS FED UP WITH HOMELESSNESS AND GOVERNMENTS MAKING IT WORSE
Earlier this year, Calgary was forced to dismantle an encampment in its downtown after it became host to 27 violent attacks in only two months. Parks throughout Halifax are now host to permanent tent cities, with even sympathetic neighbours reporting that they’ve become nightmare hubs of screaming, fights and abandoned needles. Just last month, an RCMP officer was murdered during a routine call to a Burnaby homeless encampment.
And according to a new Leger poll for Postmedia, Canadians are not only done with all of this, but they’re increasingly convinced that their governments are actively making it worse.
Of 1,534 poll respondents, a clear majority (58 per cent) reported that “homelessness is a problem in my community,” with more than a third (38 per cent) reporting that homelessness has “increased acts of violence in my community.”
A mere seven per cent think that government is “making things better.” More than double that number (16 per cent) think government is “making things worse.” And almost everyone else thinks government is doing nothing at all.
“At some point it’s a bit of a gut check in terms of ‘What are we doing here?’” said Leger’s Andrew Enns. “I think governments need to be cognizant of the fact that, at best, they’re not making a lot of progress on the homelessness issue.”
It’s not for lack of funding. In B.C. alone, the most recent budget earmarked $633 million for spending on homelessness. This included nine-figure funding to implement a “permanent housing plan” for the approximately 3,000 British Columbians who received temporary shelter spaces during the COVID-19 pandemic. With a price tag of $264 million, this works out to about $88,000 per homeless individual.
In Ontario, homelessness spending is expected to hit $446 million for the next fiscal year — and this rises to more than $1 billion when spending on housing is looped in.
The last federal budget earmarked $562.2 million to fight chronic homelessness, with billions more put towards affordable and co-op housing.
And yet, by almost every metric, Canadian homelessness continues to get worse. Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, Statistics Canada was noting an across-the-board increase in the raw numbers of Canadians on the street.
With COVID-19, the temporary closure of shelters due to social distancing made the problem more visible than ever before, with tent cities cropping up everywhere from Charlottetown, P.E.I., to Mission, B.C., to Kingston, Ont.
Canada has simultaneously witnessed a dramatic spike in homeless deaths. In 2021, 247 homeless British Columbians died — a 75 per cent increase over the year before. Just this week, new data from Toronto Public Health found that the city’s homeless death rate has doubled in just the last three years.
In Victoria, homeless encampments that began forming in the city’s Beacon Hill Park in 2020 were soon host to a “life-altering” attack on a developmentally delayed 15-year-old, the discovery of a full-sized chop shop for stolen bikes, and a van fire in which one man was killed.
In Toronto, a major encampment in the city’s Trinity Bellwoods Park caused a 450 per cent increase in fires, the scattering of more than 10,000 used needles in just three months and the routine uttering of threats against passersby and parks staff.
A tent city in Calgary was accused by police of “creating a gauntlet of violence and drug trafficking” outside one of the city’s main rehab centres. One of the tents was the site of an alleged sexual assault against a minor.
In an August press release, a coalition of Vancouver women’s centres warned that tent cities were hubs of violence against women. “With every tent city, we see a dramatic increase in gender-based violence. Women are threatened, harassed, beaten, and raped,” said Alice Kendall, Executive Director of the Downtown Eastside Women’s Centre.
A political backlash is already underway. In last month’s B.C. municipal elections, a wave of centre-right mayors were elected across B.C. due largely to their promise to aggressively tackle the issue of crime, public disorder and homelessness.
“We’re sitting by watching as business are robbed, cars are stolen from driveways, and random assaults happen on our streets,” reads the campaign platform of newly elected Kelowna Mayor Tom Dyas. In Vancouver, mayoral candidate Ken Sim won in a landslide after a campaign that pledged to pull the city out of what he called an acute “public safety crisis.”
Sim promised to hire 100 new police officers, but he also promised an additional 100 mental health nurses and the establishment of a 24-hour addiction recovery centre.
The Leger poll similarly revealed a Canadian populace that is fed up with the crime and disorder wrought by rising homelessness — but simultaneously feels responsibility and compassion for the people caught within it.
A near-unanimous 93 per cent of poll respondents supported increased funding for homelessness: More shelter spaces, more mental health treatment, more programs to get homeless Canadians into the labour force.
The most unpopular strategies to address homelessness? Police clearances of encampments, and using buses to ship homeless people out of town.
In cities like Vancouver, the last decade has seen an explicit prioritization of the “housing first” model of ending homelessness. “The answer to homelessness is housing,” went a frequently repeated line by outgoing Vancouver mayor Kennedy Stewart.
The idea is that a homeless person can’t get clean or even consider finding a job until they’re first given a stable roof over their head. The result — at least in B.C. — has been a massive push to buy up hotels and transform them into low-barrier shelters.
In just 2021, governments bought up more than a quarter billion dollars’ worth of Vancouver real estate to house 767 homeless people — an average rate of $351,000 per bed.
Paired with this has been an aggressive focus on harm reduction; the idea of making drug use safer without any underlying pressure for addicts to get clean. In 2003, Vancouver’s InSite became North America’s first state-sanctioned facility to provide medical supervision of illicit drug use. Now, safe consumption sites are either open or planned in all 10 provinces.
But as homelessness and addiction continue to get worse, even progressive circles are beginning to question the idea that the issue can ever be truly curbed without more proactive strategies to get homeless people off illicit drugs and into managed mental health treatment.
A return to institutionalization has even been pitched by David Eby, the newly minted leader of the B.C. NDP soon poised to take over as B.C. premier. In August, he proposed that British Columbians who were routinely overdosing should be forced into involuntary treatment.
“Our numbers are plunging down, B.C.’s are continuing to go up, and that is clear, it is not in dispute,” Marshall Smith, chief of staff for Alberta’s Associate Minister of Mental Health and Addictions, told reporter Geoff Russ in September.
In August, 49-year-old Chris Schwede would become the most recent person to die in a Victoria, B.C. tent encampment.
As Schwede’s sister Tammy Trausch would tell the Times Colonist, while there were plenty of resources around her brother to ensure that he could use drugs safely, at the time of his death getting a spot in a detox centre required an 111-day wait.
“There’s no such thing as safe supply because Chris was on safe supply and he’s in a morgue right now,” Trausch said.
The Postmedia/Leger poll was conducted between Oct. 28 and 30 among 1,534 adult Canadians drawn from Leger’s online panel. A margin of error cannot be calculated because online polls aren’t considered to be statistically representative.
Story by: National Post